By Jessica Lien
Carrie Figdor has a question about fruit flies.
Scientists study how the flies make decisions. Figdor, a professor in the Department of Philosophy, asks what that word means when it describes an insect.
“Humans can make decisions, and flies can make decisions,” Figdor said. “What is a decision?"
One answer treats the word as a metaphor. In that view, the fly never really decides anything. Figdor takes another approach, arguing that scientists should take such claims seriously rather than automatically dismissing them as metaphors.
Her first book, Pieces of Mind: The Proper Domain of Psychological Predicates, looks at language like this from across biology. Scientists report that plants “decide” and that bacteria “communicate.” Figdor argues that these words should be read literally. A literal claim can still turn out to be false; what matters to her is that it can be tested.
“If you say it’s metaphorical, then the question of truth or falsity doesn’t even get on the table,” she said.
Figdor makes the case with a fruit fly. In one study, scientists altered a gene called Forkhead box P, or FOXP, and timed flies as they chose between smells. Fruit flies with the altered gene took longer to make a decision than other flies. The researchers concluded that the gene helps flies gather information and reach a decision.
Humans carry a related gene, FOXP2. Mutations in it can cause speech and language difficulties.
Scientists use words such as choosing, learning, remembering, and deciding for humans and other animals alike. Many people assume the words mean something else for a creature as unlike us as a fruit fly.
Figdor reads them literally. Her evidence is a mathematical model of decision-making, first built from studies of people. The same model fits the flies. A fly does not think like a human. Deciding, she argues, is a capacity the two share, even if it works differently in each.
Her work asks how psychological words can apply across different forms of life without treating human abilities as the standard, universal definition.
A framework made for the job
Figdor perceives an overlooked debt in the language we have to describe and understand certain actions. She calls it “this big IOU.” If the words are literal, they need definitions that hold for a fly and a person alike.
She spent a few years reading philosophers of biology and psychologists, looking for something that would help her think the discrepancy through. She found it in evolutionary biology.
Researchers in the field of evolutionary biology map how living things are related on the conceptual model of the tree of life. They trace how vision evolved, from a few light-sensitive cells to complex eyes. They ask whether a structure in a bird’s brain and a structure in a mammal’s brain were inherited from the same ancestor.
Her second book, tentatively titled Species-Neutral Psychology, carries that work forward.
Mind and body
Most people accept that a human body is a mammal’s body. A human brain is a mammal’s brain, too. That is why neuroscientists can learn about the human brain by studying rats.
Psychology has no matching correlation of the mind. There is no universal definition for the word “mind.” But the idea that only humans have minds goes back thousands of years, Figdor said, and even the field of evolutionary psychology is about humans.
Calling a body “mammalian” sounds ordinary, and a great deal of scientific work stands behind the phrase. Calling a mind mammalian does not yet mean much. Figdor wants to change that.
“Psychology has been left out. It’s as if you had nothing, and then you got humans. I’d like us to think about minds the way we think about bodies,” Figdor said.
That means asking which living things have which mental features, and how those features are related across species. Figdor stresses that she is not inventing the tools for the job. Evolutionary biology already built them. Once people accept that minds evolved, she said, the tools apply.
Some of the questions are familiar. When did consciousness first appear on the tree of life? Do fish feel pain? The answers have ethical implications, but that’s not the scope of what Figdor is taking on in her research. Figdor’s work sits a step back, at the level of theory. She compares the difference to pure and applied mathematics.
That perspective opens questions about abilities researchers have traditionally examined primarily in humans.
For example, take a moment and consider the definition of the word “memory.” Did you have a human-centric definition? Many species have memory, but it doesn’t imply the same thing. Plants might even be said to “remember” certain things. What are the shared traits, and what’s different? Figdor formalizes those definitions: “To me, humans are just one species. You might as well pick blue jays or oak trees” to decide how to define a shared trait.
How are different forms of learning related? And how might those abilities have changed over time.
Research at Iowa
Before her academic career, Figdor worked for more than a decade as a journalist for The Associated Press. When she joined the University of Iowa faculty in 2007, she wanted to be at a research-intensive university with graduate programs—a place where research is a key mission.
Along with philosophy, she holds faculty appointments in the Department of Psychological and Brain Sciences and the Interdisciplinary Graduate Program in Neuroscience. She also runs a working group on the evolution of cognition, where graduate students and faculty from across campus discuss papers.
In the classroom, Figdor keeps her own positions in the background, teaching the material the course calls for. If she disagrees with a reading, she may say so and move on.
Figdor’s interest in other species runs wide. She has a research project with dolphins and bonobos. She calls kea, the world’s only alpine parrot hailing from New Zealand, amazing, smart, and super curious. People focus on humans, Figdor said, because people are human. The tree of life is much larger.
“From my perspective, each species is unique and cool in its own way,” she said.