The Power of Film

BY: SARA DIEDRICH  |  2015.09.02  |  10:54 AM

Social scientists have long argued documentary films are powerful tools for social change. 

But a University of Iowa sociologist and his co-researchers are the first to use the Internet and social media to systematically show how a documentary film shaped public perception and ultimately led to municipal bans on hydraulic fracking.  


Professor Ion "Bodi" Vasi

By measuring an uptick in online searches as well as social media chatter and mass media coverage, Ion Bogdan Vasi, corresponding author of a new study, demonstrated how local screenings of Gasland—a 2010 American documentary that focused on communities affected by natural gas drillingaffected the public debate on hydraulic fracking. Additionally, Vasi and his collaborators demonstrated how local screenings were linked to an increase in anti-fracking mobilizations that, in turn, influenced the passage of local bans on fracking.   

"There are few studies that describe the effect of documentaries on collective behaviors and social movement campaigns," says Vasi, an associate professor with a joint appointment in the Department of Sociology in the College of Liberal Arts and Sciences and the Department of Management and Organizations in the Tippie College of Business at the UI. "They used anecdotal evidence but not rigorous research." 

The study, "'No Fracking Way!' Documentary Film, Discursive Opportunity and Local Opposition against Hydraulic Fracturing in the United States, 2010-2013," was published online Sept. 2 and will appear in the October print issue of the American Sociological Review.  

According to the study, "screenings of Gasland in different locations had an effect upon the mobilization of local campaigns against the controversial practice of hydraulic fracturing; in turn, those local mobilizations made local policymakers significantly more likely to take action to ban the practice of fracking." 

Vasi, who studies collective behaviors, says the documentary worked as a catalyst for policy changes in the Marcellus shale region (Pennsylvania, Ohio, New York, and West Virginia) where Gasland was filmed.   

"The documentary clearly made an impact, but it was indirect," he says. "On average, more screenings led to more mobilizations, which led to policy changes." 

Vasi says he chose Gasland for his study because it contains dramatic images similar to those of the burning Cuyahoga River that helped launch the environmental movement in 1969. In Gasland, viewers witness people set fire to tap water allegedly contaminated by fracking in Pennsylvania and other states. Another reason for his choice was that, at the time of the study, scientists didn't agree on the dangers of hydraulic fracking—a method of horizontal drilling into shale formations.

During his research, Vasi zeroed in on two time periods for his data collection: June 2010, when Gasland was released on HBO, and February 2011, when the documentary was nominated for an Academy Award.  

"For the period of the study the number of Google searches for 'fracking' was much larger than for Gasland, with two exceptions: the months when the documentary was released on HBO and when it was nominated for an Oscar," Vasi says. "In fact, in June 2010 the number of searches for Gasland was four times higher than the number of searches for 'fracking,' indicating that the documentary created significant interest in the topic among the general public."   

Researchers also found that chatter on Twitter about fracking increased over time, particularly after Gasland was released on HBO and again when it was nominated for an Oscar. The study shows "chatter increases by approximately 6 percent after the release and by approximately 9 percent after the nomination compared to the previous month." 

Finally, mass media coverage of fracking—as measured by newspaper articles—increases over time, particularly after Gasland's release and award nomination. According to the study, "more than half of the articles that mention fracking in June 2010 and January 2011 also mention Gasland." 

However, Vasi says negative public sentiment about hydraulic fracking was most readily apparent in online activity and social media chatter because traditional newspapers are obligated to show both sides of an issue. 

He also said that fracking serves as an excellent example of how community activists grapple with contentious energy issues and the environment, particularly because of recent legislation that makes local fracking bans illegal in states such as Texas. 

Authors of the study hope future studies will investigate the effects of other documentary films and see why some films lead to large-scale mobilizations and others do not.  

Contributing authors include Edward Walker of UCLA, John Johnson of Harmony Institute, and Hui Fen Tan of Cornell University. The study received support for some of the data collection from the Harmony Institute.

http://now.uiowa.edu/2015/09/power-film

Other articles in this Newsletter

  • SIP Award Winner

    Sociologically Imaginative Pictures (SIP) awards are presented for the best pictures capturing a sociological perspective. The winner of this year's award, James Year, describes the sociological theme of his photo.

  • Engines of Anxiety

    UI Sociology Professor Mike Sauder and his co-author Wendy Espeland describe their new book on rankings in higher education, Engines of Anxiety.

  • Seashore Hall

    Professor Karen Heimer, the chair of our department, welcomes the readers and provides an update on recent happenings at Iowa Sociology.

  • Iowa Sociological Association

    In the end of April, department of Sociology hosted the annual meeting of the Iowa Sociological Association (ISA), that brought together students from University of Iowa, University of Northern Iowa, Central College, Luther College, Cornell College, Loras College, Grinnell College and Kirkwood Community College. 

  • Sociology Students

    Beginning in the fall of 2016, the Sociology Department will provide students the opportunity to major in Criminology, Law, and Justice with a Bachelors of Arts or Bachelors of Science degree. 

  • This past October, the Public Policy Center, College of Education, and UI Sociology Department co-sponsored a research symposium attended by 75 graduate students and faculty from the University of Iowa and several other Midwest universities.

  • TILE Classroom

    In 2010, in an effort to encourage student-centered teaching, the University of Iowa created the TILE (“transform, interact, learn, engage”) program.  To practice interactive teaching, many sociology professors use TILE classrooms in their courses.

  • Sociology Club

    This has been an exciting year for the Sociology Club! From lectures by renowned sociologists to career development opportunities, the Club hosted a range of useful and fun events for anyone interested in the discipline. 

  • Natalie Veldhouse

    Alumna Natalie Veldhouse (Class of 2015) has been using skills developed in sociology classrooms in her work at the Crisis Center of Johnson County, where she conducts research on food insecurity. We interviewed Natalie about using sociological imagination in her new job.

  • Graduate Student Presentation

    University of Iowa sociology graduate students engage in a variety of research projects. Their work includes qualitative, quantitative, individual and macro-level analyses, in a variety of subareas within sociology including social psychology, crime, social capital, education, gender and ethnicity. 

  • Dr. Alison Bianchi and team of researchers at the Center

    Professor Bianchi, along with undergraduate and graduate research assistants, investigates the problems facing the growing population of Chinese students at Iowa.